Social

What Spreads

Content

Academic
Effort: low
Volume: medium

Myth:Make it positive and it will spread.

Evidence:Analyzing every New York Times article emailed over three months plus follow-up experiments: positive content is shared more than negative, but the deeper driver is physiological arousal - awe, anger and anxiety spread, sadness suppresses - with surprise, interest and practical usefulness adding independent lift.

The Nuance

The experiments show the emotion effect is causal, driven by activation level, and holds controlling for prominence and usefulness.

The Receipt

What Makes Online Content Viral?

Jonah Berger & Katherine L. Milkman, Journal of Marketing Research · 2012 · Academic

Impact7.6/10
Consensus8.4/10
Evidence86/100

Channels: content · social

Related Cribs

Distribution mechanics

Link in comments on LinkedIn

Myth:"Link in comments" is a busted hack — LinkedIn stopped penalising outbound links.

Evidence:Outbound links in the post body still suppress reach. Algorithm InSights (1.8M posts) puts the body-link penalty near 50% of organic reach, and controlled A/B tests show first-comment placement recovering most of it: GrowthRocks measured 2.9x reach for link-in-comment in round one and 1.8x in round two — with more clicks, not fewer.

Impact9/10
Consensus7/10

Engagement signals

Dwell time beats reactions

Myth:Likes are the signal that drives distribution.

Evidence:LinkedIn's own ranking model uses a dwell-time prediction weighted independently of — and more heavily than — likes, with no fixed second threshold. Content that gets read all the way through outranks content that gets tapped and skipped.

Impact9/10
Consensus8/10

Engagement signals

Comment weighting vs likes

Myth:A comment is worth 15x a like — every creator says so.

Evidence:The 15x multiplier has no traceable primary source. AuthoredUp's analysis of 621,833 posts puts a comment at roughly 2x a like, a save at roughly 2x a meaningful comment, and threaded replies at up to 2.4x more reach. Comments still beat likes — just not by an order of magnitude.

Impact8/10
Consensus8/10

Myth:Your reach dropped because you stopped posting enough.

Evidence:Algorithm InSights (1.8M posts) documents organic reach falling by nearly 50% as LinkedIn shifted from a social graph to an interest graph. Baseline reach is structurally lower; the model now rewards demonstrated expertise signals over reach-chasing volume.

Impact8/10
Consensus8/10

Crib of the Week

One crib in your inbox every Monday. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.